Discount Tire Choices

[Milocka]

Hi All - I will not buy tires from anywhere other than discount tire. I've been a lifelong customer starting with my first car when I was 16. 22 years later, never bought a tire elsewhere. With that said, I've got China bombs on my Laredo 5th wheel and will be replacing them next week. The question is which tire to replace them with?

I've seen good reviews of the Carlisle Trail RH and they are about $40 less per tire than the Maxxis 8008's.

Both are load range E and 10 ply. Current bombs are range D and 8 ply I believe.

Which tire should I go with? I know I'll get 10 different opinions but I am looking for real world use cases to try and make an educated decision.

Are the Maxxis tires worth $200 more for a set of 5 compared got the Carlisles? (Replacing spare too)

Thanks in advance for the opinions and recommendations.