Which brand to replace G rated tires?

Old Mustanger · 09-02-2023, 07:27 PM

My Sailun ST235/85R/16G tires have aged out and showing a lot of wear, I was looking on line today for where to get new Sailuns or Hercules and found that Walmart actually carries Carlisle in this size.

I always thought of Carlisle as making a dependable tire in smaller sizes but was unaware they made these 14 ply monsters.

Any thoughts as to which of the 3 brands may be the better investment?

RickV · 09-03-2023, 12:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old Mustanger

My Sailun ST235/85R/16G tires have aged out and showing a lot of wear, I was looking on line today for where to get new Sailuns or Hercules and found that Walmart actually carries Carlisle in this size.

I always thought of Carlisle as making a dependable tire in smaller sizes but was unaware they made these 14 ply monsters.

Any thoughts as to which of the 3 brands may be the better investment?

All I can say is that Saliun's have never left me down on different 5vers and it seems like they did the job for you. The Old Adage "if it ain't Broke, don't fix it" comes to mind.
Also if you have a Mavis Tire near you they usually have good prices on the Saliuns.

xrated · 09-03-2023, 03:59 AM

I bought 6 new Sailun S637s (235/85R16) around the 1st of July this year from Walmart online. They were $142/each plus tax. The load capacity of that tire is 4400 lbs.....about 300 more than the 235/80R/16 (which were not on sale). Since I don't trust Walmart to do the mounting/balancing, I took them to my local tire dealer and had that done. Total price, for everything was $1142.

ChuckS · 09-03-2023, 05:46 AM

Hercules and Sailun are excellent .. I would also not have an issue with Carisile 14 ply ..

TXiceman · 09-03-2023, 06:03 AM

I ran Goodyear G614 tires the last 5 years on my 3 axle trailer. Never a problem. Pricey, yes, but no problems.

Ken

Old Mustanger · 09-03-2023, 07:38 PM

Thanks for the replies, I'm probably going to shop price and then make a decision.
I also have to find a tire shop that will mount and balance them, the one I used for the last set was not to thrilled with the amount of work the 14ply tires took.
I'll let y'all know, might be a little while, we are not planning any trips for now as we have a new granddaughter on her way soon.

RickV · 09-04-2023, 01:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old Mustanger

Thanks for the replies, I'm probably going to shop price and then make a decision.
I also have to find a tire shop that will mount and balance them, the one I used for the last set was not to thrilled with the amount of work the 14ply tires took.
I'll let y'all know, might be a little while, we are not planning any trips for now as we have a new granddaughter on her way soon.

While Discount Tire does not sale Saliuns not sure about the others discussed you may be able to do what I did with my dually tires see post 8 in this thread https://www.keystoneforums.com/forum...050#post546050

Old Mustanger · 09-04-2023, 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RickV

While Discount Tire does not sale Saliuns not sure about the others discussed you may be able to do what I did with my dually tires see post 8 in this thread https://www.keystoneforums.com/forum...050#post546050

Actually I had checked Discount tire before I got the current set of Sailuns, at that time they were handling the Hercules but I looked at them on line the other day and nothing came up for the ST235/8516G. I think I'll stop looking on line and start making phone calls.

Raptor Dave · 09-05-2023, 05:37 AM

We've been happy with Sailuns in the past also.
Give "Simple tire" a look on line.
Used them several times for different applications.
They ship to a local tire shop so you don't have to handle the tires and their installation fees are reasonable.

travelin texans · 09-05-2023, 08:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TXiceman

I ran Goodyear G614 tires the last 5 years on my 3 axle trailer. Never a problem. Pricey, yes, but no problems.

Ken

On the 5er listed in my signature GY 614s came on it from the factory. After 4-5 years & 40-50k miles they needed replaced.
I found a deal online, actually it was Performance Trailer Braking that did my disc brakes, for 4 -17.5" H rated Sailun tires mounted on new aluminum wheels for less than the replacement price of 3 of the GY 614s, it was a no brainer, so I would agree the GYs are a bit pricey. The PTB crew put them on once they completed the disc brake upgrade. Both the brakes & Sailuns was the best upgrade I ever spent $$ on.

TXiceman · 09-05-2023, 10:36 AM

travelin Texas, I ran the G614s on my three axle 19,000 LB trailer for 5 years and wear was normal and still decent tires when I sold it. The first set of tires on the trailer was Hankook F19 MaxiVantage G rated and never seconds trouble from them.

I went with GY on the next set due to the GY warranty.

Ken

Mikelff · 09-10-2023, 08:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Old Mustanger

My Sailun ST235/85R/16G tires have aged out and showing a lot of wear, I was looking on line today for where to get new Sailuns or Hercules and found that Walmart actually carries Carlisle in this size.

I always thought of Carlisle as making a dependable tire in smaller sizes but was unaware they made these 14 ply monsters.

Any thoughts as to which of the 3 brands may be the better investment?

I needed a new spare and bought a Carlisle at Discount tire. They were competitive with Sailin pricing at the time. They mounted for free. From my research Carlisle makes a good tire compatible to Sailin. I have Sailin on my rig now. Discount tire mounted them for me but charged me to do it which was fine since I didn’t buy the tires from them. Next set of tires I may try the Carlisle. I’ll Make that decision at that time.

MattE303 · 09-11-2023, 02:20 PM

out of curiosity, how many years do you have on the Sailuns to consider them "aged out"? I'm on 6 years with mine and wondering if I should replace them. I know most people say 5 years (or something close to that) for trailer tires, but mine look brand new, no drying or cracking, no real signs of wear or damage. I keep them covered, trailer is parked under cover at home, and haven't put a ton of miles on 'em. Would like to get one more year.

Old Mustanger · 09-11-2023, 07:26 PM

5 years by the sidewall date code. I've only been running them 4 years (another reason I won't go back to where I purchased them, big argument when I pointed out that they were already a year old). besides aging out they got a good many miles on them and are showing wear, one of them especially, I'm going to have my axles checked, may have a bent spindle.

RV Vacation · 09-12-2023, 02:09 PM

Just want to thank all who posted on this thread. I just purchased our first Montana and truthfully thought I would be immediately replacing the Sailuns as we extensively travel.

Thanks for putting my mind at ease regarding the Sailun tires, I honestly thought 'OMG' "maypops" when I first saw them mounted on our 5er.

Thanks again, be well and safe travels.

**sourdough** · 09-12-2023, 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RV Vacation

Just want to thank all who posted on this thread. I just purchased our first Montana and truthfully thought I would be immediately replacing the Sailuns as we extensively travel.

Thanks for putting my mind at ease regarding the Sailun tires, I honestly thought 'OMG' "maypops" when I first saw them mounted on our 5er.

Thanks again, be well and safe travels.

Did you buy the Montana new? I'm thinking they started putting the Sailuns on them??

pawpaw · 09-13-2023, 06:30 AM

[QUOTE=RV Vacation;546693]Just want to thank all who posted on this thread. I just purchased our first Montana and truthfully thought I would be immediately replacing the Sailuns as we extensively travel.

Thanks for putting my mind at ease regarding the Sailun tires, I honestly thought 'OMG' "maypops" when I first saw them mounted on our 5er.

Thanks again, be well and safe travels.[/QUOTE

Had Sailun's on our 2015 Fuzion...great tires even though the made in China made me think otherwise.

Kzneft · 09-13-2023, 06:34 AM

I love my Sailuns. I got mine at Big-O-tires.

RV Vacation · 09-13-2023, 07:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sourdough

Did you buy the Montana new? I'm thinking they started putting the Sailuns on them??

Hello and congratulations on your marriage, my wife and I are approaching 50 years together, the past 5 full time RVing. Mercy, will miracles never cease?

Yes we just purchased our Montana 3901RK and just three weeks ago. So far so good. Sooooo much more comfortable than our MoHo. Howeverrrr, not new to RVs, we do expect some 'hiccups' as we continue our full time RV living.

I do admit, seeing Sailun tires installed on our Montana had me thinking about the purchase. Of course the rear kitchen overrode my tire fears by a vote of 1 to nothing as my wife exercised her veto powers.

Even though I know I can have the Sailuns' replaced at my convivence, I do appreciate the comments posted and so I shall give the tires a chance on our upcoming 4200 mile adventure.

Be well and safe travels.

John

RV Vacation · 09-13-2023, 07:28 AM

Thank you for taking the time and letting me know your experience with Sailun Tires. I have decided to leave those on our Montana and give them a 4000 mile road test this coming October.

We hope to be passing through Louisiana at the finish of our trip by Octobers end. Beautiful country.

Be well and safe travels.

You may also like: